Why Providers Should be Documenting “Evidence of” a Diagnosis Based on Clinical Findings

Why Providers Should be Documenting “Evidence of” a Diagnosis Based on Clinical Findings

CDI and coding professionals should consider the totality of the record when determining if a diagnosis is reportable.

Some diagnoses can be validated with diagnostic evidence e.g., x-ray, CT scan, ultrasound, etc. while other diagnoses are based on a provider’s experience and patient presentation.  Many clinical documentation integrity (CDI) and coding professionals rely upon the Official Coding Guideline for uncertain diagnoses (Section III.C) for these types of diagnoses which states,

“If the diagnosis documented at the time of discharge is qualified as “probable,” “suspected,” “likely,” “questionable,” “possible,” or “still to be ruled out,” “compatible with,” “consistent with,” or other similar terms indicating uncertainty, code the condition as if it existed or was established. The bases for these guidelines are the diagnostic workup, arrangements for further workup or observation, and initial therapeutic approach that correspond most closely with the established diagnosis. Note: This guideline is applicable only to inpatient admissions to short-term, acute, long-term care and psychiatric hospitals.”

But what CDI professionals may not be aware of there are several American Hospital Association (AHA) Coding Clinics related to this coding guideline that clarify what terminology is considered “uncertain.”  Why is this important?  Because providers usually don’t document uncertain diagnoses at the time of discharge unless coached to do so.  It is also important to note that the above uncertain diagnosis guideline only applies to the inpatient setting because the outpatient setting also has an uncertain diagnosis guideline (Section IV.H) that states,

“Do not code diagnoses documented as “probable”, “suspected,” “questionable,” “rule out,” “compatible with,” “consistent with,” or “working diagnosis” or other similar terms indicating uncertainty. Rather, code the condition(s) to the highest degree of certainty for that encounter/visit, such as symptoms, signs, abnormal test results, or other reason for the visit. Please note: This differs from the coding practices used by short-term, acute care, long-term care and psychiatric hospitals.

This context is needed to accurately interpret AHA Coding Clinic Advice related to uncertain diagnoses.  Because the guideline includes the phrase “other similar terms,” Coding Clinic has been asked about different qualifiers and if their use results in an uncertain diagnosis or not.  Consequently, Coding Clinic determined “concern for is a term that should be interpreted as an uncertain diagnosis and coded following the guideline for ‘uncertain diagnoses’ in the inpatient setting (Issue 1, 2018);” and appears to be “fits the definition of a probably or suspected condition that would not be coded in the outpatient setting (Issue 3, 2009).”

However, the Issue 3, 2009 AHA Coding Clinic also states, “when the provider documents ‘evidence of’ a particular condition, it is not considered an uncertain diagnosis and should be appropriately coded and reported in the outpatient setting.”  Some may think this advice only applies to the outpatient setting, but that would be an inaccurate interpretation because the above Coding Guidelines demonstrate that the outpatient coding guideline is much more restrictive than the inpatient coding guideline. 

Uncertain diagnoses cannot be reported in the outpatient setting but can be reported in the inpatient setting “if documented as such at the time of discharge.”  If “evidence of” is not considered a qualifier that results in an uncertain diagnosis in the outpatient setting, then the same would be true for the inpatient setting. 

Why does this matter?  Because if a provider documents “evidence of gram-negative pneumonia” or some other clinical diagnosis in a progress note, and the diagnosis is supported with clinical evidence, and meets the definition of a reportable diagnosis or principal diagnosis; the diagnosis can be reported. 

In my opinion, it is much more likely a provider will document “evidence of” a diagnosis in a progress note, than qualify a diagnosis as uncertain at the time of discharge.  I also feel like use of “evidence of” gives the provider a little bit of wiggle room when they are making a clinical diagnosis, one that cannot be easily validated by diagnostics, but is based on presenting signs and symptoms as well as response to treatment. 

There are several instances when providers may rely upon clinical findings to either make a diagnosis or provide more specificity about a diagnosis e.g., specifying the type of pneumonia, ischemic stroke, metabolic encephalopathy, etc. and use of “evidence of” may be appropriate due to a lack of diagnostic evidence. Providers aren’t required to prove a diagnosis beyond a shadow of doubt for it to be reportable, but many are hesitant to document a diagnosis until they reach a degree of certainty due to the potential for liability.  

Each provider will have their own threshold of how much clinical evidence they need to make a definitive diagnosis, which is allowable under Coding Guideline 19 that states,

“The assignment of a diagnosis code is based on the provider’s diagnostic statement that the condition exists. The provider’s statement that the patient has a particular condition is sufficient. Code assignment is not based on clinical criteria used by the provider to establish the diagnosis. If there is conflicting medical record documentation, query the provider.”

The guideline doesn’t say there must be diagnostic evidence to support a reportable diagnosis, only that the provider must document that the condition exists.  Of course, we know there must be clinical evidence to support every reported diagnosis to avoid a clinical validation denial, but we often forget the importance of patient history and presentation.  For example, providers in the office setting will often make a diagnosis of pneumonia without a chest x-ray to confirm the diagnosis. 

Just to be clear, a diagnosis qualified with “evidence of” will also need to be clinically valid, but the validation may be, for example, the presence of pneumonia, but not the causative organism.  In this example the use of “evidence of” allows the provider to further specify the type of pneumonia when they are unlikely to isolate the causative organism through diagnostic tests but can make an educated guess about the causative organism based on the patient’s history, presentation, and response to treatment. 

Another example is when determining the type of encephalopathy in a complex patient.  Rather than documenting “likely metabolic encephalopathy” which can only be reported if documented at the time of discharge, the provider can document “evidence of metabolic encephalopathy” in any note because it “evidence of” is does not make metabolic encephalopathy an uncertain diagnosis.  When educating providers about “evidence of,” I also educate them to document if the condition is later ruled out.  I find this to be a more successful approach than hoping a provider will document an uncertain diagnosis at the time of discharge. 

Additionally, most of us have been inaccurately applying the inpatient uncertain diagnosis guideline which states, “The bases for these guidelines are the diagnostic workup, arrangements for further workup or observation, and initial therapeutic approach that correspond most closely with the established diagnosis.”  Use of the word “and” in this guideline implies that all conditions must be met for the Coding Guideline to apply.  One of those conditions is arrangements for further workup or observation.  If you encourage providers to document uncertain diagnoses at the time of discharge, also educate them document how the condition will be followed up post-discharge. 

I’m not sure why many CDI and coding professionals prefer to rely on the inpatient uncertain diagnosis guideline rather than educating providers to use “evidence of” when they lack diagnostic certainty to support an appropriate diagnosis, but I hope this article will encourage more of you to use this approach. I also encourage CDI and coding professionals to consider the totality of the record when determining if a diagnosis is reportable because providers will often copy and paste documentation where a diagnosis is uncertain pending further workup into subsequent progress notes or even the discharge summary making it appear that a diagnosis is still being worked up, but the diagnosis was ruled out or lacks clinical validation to be reported. 

Before applying the inpatient uncertain diagnosis guideline validate the diagnosis was not already worked up and ruled out or that there is sufficient clinical evidence for the diagnosis to be reported.

Programming note: Listen to Cheryl Ericson’s live CDI report today on Talk Ten Tuesdays with Dr. Erica Remer and Chuck Buck at 10 Eastern.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Cheryl Ericson, RN, MS, CCDS, CDIP

Cheryl is the Senior Director of Clinical Policy and Education, Brundage Group. She is an experienced revenue cycle expert and is known internationally for her work as a CDI professional. Cheryl has helped establish industry guidance through contributions to ACDIS white papers and several AHIMA Practice Briefs in the areas of CDI, Denials, Quality, Querying and HIM Technology.

Related Stories

Preparing for CJR-X

Preparing for CJR-X

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) recently provided an overview of the upcoming Comprehensive Care for Joint Replacement Expanded Model (CJR-X). Thank you

Read More

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

Inpatient Ulcers and Gangrene: Avoid FY 2027 ICD-10-CM Coding, Sequencing, and Documentation Errors

Avoid costly inpatient coding errors involving ulcers and gangrene. This practical FY 2027 ICD-10-CM webcast clarifies pressure injury staging, non-pressure ulcer severity, diagnosis sequencing, documentation requirements, and POA reporting. Through real-world cases, gain the confidence to make defensible coding decisions, reduce denials, strengthen compliance, and support accurate reimbursement.

November 4, 2026

One Chart, Five Truths: How CDI Prevents the Same Diagnosis from Becoming Five Different Outcomes

What happens when everyone reviews the same chart, but reaches a different conclusion? In this case-based clinical documentation integrity (CDI) webcast, Penny Jefferson examines how documentation involving clinical support, timing, causation, linkage, and terminology can produce very different outcomes for ICD-10 coding, reimbursement, quality, risk adjustment, medical necessity, denials, and compliance. Using cases involving postoperative respiratory failure, severe malnutrition, and encephalopathy, you’ll learn the practical CLEAR framework to help attendees learn to evaluate whether a diagnosis is codeable, consistent, specific, reportable, and ultimately defensible across the different teams and systems that rely on the medical record.

September 30, 2026

Mastering Spinal Fusion Coding for Inpatient Facilities: ICD-10-PCS Precision, Documentation, and MS-DRG Impact

Spinal fusion cases are among the most complex inpatient procedures to code, where even minor ICD-10-PCS errors can affect MS-DRG assignment, reimbursement, compliance, and audit outcomes. This practical webcast provides a step-by-step framework for interpreting operative reports, assigning accurate ICD-10-PCS codes, recognizing documentation gaps, and confidently coding complex fusion procedures. You’ll leave with practical tools that improve coding accuracy, reduce denials and audit risk, and strengthen documentation-driven reimbursement decisions.

July 29, 2026

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

Radiation Oncology Fundamentals: Coding, Billing & Compliance for Hospital Outpatient & Professional Services

Now Available On Demand

Join Michael Calahan, PA, MBA for this radiation oncology coding and compliance webcast as he explains the fundamentals of coding, billing, reporting, and documentation for hospital outpatient and professional services. Learn how the 2026 radiation therapy coding changes affect current practices, how to distinguish technical and professional services, and how to address bundling, units, frequency, modifiers, and documentation requirements. Michael will also help you identify radiation oncology coding and billing vulnerabilities that could lead to denials, overpayments, repayment demands, or federal audit exposure.

October 20, 2026

Trending News

Prepare for the 2025 CMS IPPS Final Rule with ICD10monitor’s IPPSPalooza! Click HERE to learn more

Get 15% OFF on all educational webcasts at ICD10monitor with code JULYFOURTH24 until July 4, 2024—start learning today!

This Memorial Day, we honor those who gave all for our freedom. Take 20% off sitewide through May 29 with code MEMORIAL26 at checkout

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 1 with code CYBER25

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24