Patient Satisfaction – An Unreliable and Dangerous Measure

Patient Satisfaction – An Unreliable and Dangerous Measure

Many of you have heard me criticize our dependence on patient satisfaction scores as a quality measure.

Back in 2012, researchers at the University of California-Davis published a study demonstrating that higher patient satisfaction was associated with less emergency department use, but with greater inpatient use, higher overall health care and prescription drug expenditures, and increased mortality.

And now there is new research to support this contention. A new study was recently released that once again supports my viewpoint. A group of orthopedic surgeons at Stanford Medicine randomized almost 1,500 patients who were having elective hip or knee replacement.

After they went home, half of the patients received a personal thank-you card from the surgeon along with a bouquet of flowers, and half did not. All of the patients received their usual post-surgery Press Ganey survey.

And as you can guess, the scores from the patients who received flowers were statistically higher than those who did not. Interestingly, the patients who received flowers not only rated their physician higher, but also the hospital experience. Think about that: same physicians, same nurses, same hospital, but better scores simply because they received flowers after discharge.

If a study showing increased mortality didn’t sway those who support patient satisfaction surveys, then one showing the influence of a bouquet of flowers is unlikely to change that. So maybe those with low scores just need to start sending flowers and get that additional quality money from the payers and a higher star rating to advertise.

Now, do not get me wrong here. I do think patients deserve quality care, and to be treated properly. But I think we need a way to measure patient engagement and use that, rather than these dangerous and imprecise measures of satisfaction.

Moving on, I talk often of the utility of online discussion groups in our work. Posts about hard cases, regulatory questions, and more abound. But remember that what you read on the Internet is not always correct.

There was a recent discussion on a Facebook case manager forum that illustrates this. A case manager asked: “Are total hip and knee revisions coded as inpatient, or can they be coded as outpatient procedures?” One respondent wrote “usually outpatient in a bed,” and another wrote “same-day surgery.” Another wrote “used to be IPO (inpatient only), but changed about two years ago.” Another wrote “TKA are always outpatient unless there is a complication.” That person went on to say, “none of my hips get out in less than two midnights.”

What’s wrong here? Well first, until we have Medicare for All, or some variation thereof, there are a myriad of payers, all with their own rules. So, was this referring to Medicare or commercial patients? We don’t know, because they did not specify.

But from the responses, most assumed Medicare, and sadly, most responses were wrong. Revision surgery is still on the inpatient-only list, so it is inpatient only for Medicare and Medicare Advantage, and is not proposed to change for 2025.

Then, even if referring to first-time surgery, the statement about “outpatient unless a complication” is wrong. The Medicare case-by-case exception allows inpatient admission prior to surgery due to risk. And what about the hospital where all hip replacements stay two days, where others go home the same day? How is that appropriate in 2024?

I love online forums, but please “trust but verify.”

EDITOR’S NOTE:

The opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views or opinions of MedLearn Media. We provide a platform for diverse perspectives, but the content and opinions expressed herein are the author’s own. MedLearn Media does not endorse or guarantee the accuracy of the information presented. Readers are encouraged to critically evaluate the content and conduct their own research. Any actions taken based on this article are at the reader’s own discretion.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

Ronald Hirsch, MD, FACP, ACPA-C, CHCQM, CHRI

Ronald Hirsch, MD, is vice president of the Regulations and Education Group at R1 Physician Advisory Services. Dr. Hirsch’s career in medicine includes many clinical leadership roles at healthcare organizations ranging from acute-care hospitals and home health agencies to long-term care facilities and group medical practices. In addition to serving as a medical director of case management and medical necessity reviewer throughout his career, Dr. Hirsch has delivered numerous peer lectures on case management best practices and is a published author on the topic. He is a member of the Credentials Council and Government Affairs Committee of the American College of Physician Advisors, on the advisory board of the National Association of Healthcare Revenue Integrity, a member of the American Case Management Association, and a Fellow of the American College of Physicians. Dr. Hirsch is a member of the RACmonitor editorial board and is regular panelist on Monitor Mondays. The opinions expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views, policies, or opinions of R1 RCM, Inc. or R1 Physician Advisory Services (R1 PAS).

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

Inpatient Ulcers and Gangrene: Avoid FY 2027 ICD-10-CM Coding, Sequencing, and Documentation Errors

Avoid costly inpatient coding errors involving ulcers and gangrene. This practical FY 2027 ICD-10-CM webcast clarifies pressure injury staging, non-pressure ulcer severity, diagnosis sequencing, documentation requirements, and POA reporting. Through real-world cases, gain the confidence to make defensible coding decisions, reduce denials, strengthen compliance, and support accurate reimbursement.

November 4, 2026

One Chart, Five Truths: How CDI Prevents the Same Diagnosis from Becoming Five Different Outcomes

What happens when everyone reviews the same chart, but reaches a different conclusion? In this case-based clinical documentation integrity (CDI) webcast, Penny Jefferson examines how documentation involving clinical support, timing, causation, linkage, and terminology can produce very different outcomes for ICD-10 coding, reimbursement, quality, risk adjustment, medical necessity, denials, and compliance. Using cases involving postoperative respiratory failure, severe malnutrition, and encephalopathy, you’ll learn the practical CLEAR framework to help attendees learn to evaluate whether a diagnosis is codeable, consistent, specific, reportable, and ultimately defensible across the different teams and systems that rely on the medical record.

September 30, 2026

Mastering Spinal Fusion Coding for Inpatient Facilities: ICD-10-PCS Precision, Documentation, and MS-DRG Impact

Spinal fusion cases are among the most complex inpatient procedures to code, where even minor ICD-10-PCS errors can affect MS-DRG assignment, reimbursement, compliance, and audit outcomes. This practical webcast provides a step-by-step framework for interpreting operative reports, assigning accurate ICD-10-PCS codes, recognizing documentation gaps, and confidently coding complex fusion procedures. You’ll leave with practical tools that improve coding accuracy, reduce denials and audit risk, and strengthen documentation-driven reimbursement decisions.

July 29, 2026

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

Radiation Oncology Fundamentals: Coding, Billing & Compliance for Hospital Outpatient & Professional Services

Now Available On Demand

Join Michael Calahan, PA, MBA for this radiation oncology coding and compliance webcast as he explains the fundamentals of coding, billing, reporting, and documentation for hospital outpatient and professional services. Learn how the 2026 radiation therapy coding changes affect current practices, how to distinguish technical and professional services, and how to address bundling, units, frequency, modifiers, and documentation requirements. Michael will also help you identify radiation oncology coding and billing vulnerabilities that could lead to denials, overpayments, repayment demands, or federal audit exposure.

October 20, 2026

Trending News

Celebrate Lab Week with MedLearn! Sign up to win one year of our Laboratory All Access Pass! Click here to learn more →

Have a Medicare regulation question you’d love Dr. Hirsch to answer? Now is your chance! CLICK HERE to learn more→

Happy National Doctor’s Day! Learn how to get a complimentary webcast on ‘Decoding Social Admissions’ as a token of our heartfelt appreciation! Click here to learn more →

This Memorial Day, we honor those who gave all for our freedom. Take 20% off sitewide through May 29 with code MEMORIAL26 at checkout

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 1 with code CYBER25

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24