The Case Against Percentage Discounts on Billed Charges

The Case Against Percentage Discounts on Billed Charges

While it is common to have payer contracts include a substantial percentage discount off of your billed charge, the practice creates avoidable risk.

Healthcare pricing is atypical, or maybe even unique. While some industries have unusual pricing, such as the dynamic pricing used by airlines that can result in two people in the same row having paid radically different fares, in that case the consumers have explicitly agreed to the deal. It’s rare to see situations in which transactions occur in the absence of any prior agreement about the price. 

One of the few times I can think of when people periodically buy a product not knowing the price is the “special” in a restaurant. But typically, the waiter discloses the charge. When a buyer and seller enter into a deal without an explicit agreement on reimbursement, you have what’s called an “implied contract.” The buyer agrees to pay, and the seller agrees to accept, a “reasonable amount.” In the event of a dispute, the judge will make a decision about what “reasonable” is.

You can see this play out in the independent dispute resolution (IDR) process of the No Surprises Act. Common sense will tell you the sorts of things a judge might consider when determining reasonability.

Obviously, market data from other organizations will be a factor. But the rate that your organization accepts as payment from other similarly situated patients seems like an extraordinarily compelling piece of evidence.

Imagine the following scenario: the bill charged for a service is $1,000. You have contracts with many insurers wherein they pay you about 60 percent of your billed charges; in other words, the contract’s insurer pays you $600 for the service. You have a policy that says uninsured patients pay 70 percent of your billed charges, or $700, for the service.

Now imagine you’re the judge.

A patient with indemnity insurance receives the service. The indemnity insurer balked at the $1,000 bill, claiming it’s too high. “Other insurance pays $600, and patients without insurance pay $700. We should not have to pay $1,000.” How would you rule?

While I’m typically not terribly sympathetic to insurance companies, in this case I think the indemnity insurer has a pretty good point. If an uninsured patient walking in off the street is going to pay $700, why should their insured patients walking in off the street be expected to pay more, in the absence of an exclusive agreement?

My main point is that when most patients are paying 20, 30, or even 40 percent less than your billed charge, there’s a compelling argument that your fee is 20, 30, or even 40 percent lower than you claim it to be. I can make arguments to defend the arrangements, but there is a real risk those arguments won’t carry the day.

As a result, my advice is to avoid situations in which you have significant percentage discounts, whether they are agreed to contractually or established via policy, unless it’s something provided to a patient with demonstrated financial hardship. While not perfect, an agreed-upon price is far superior to a percentage discount. Some of the same issues exist, but at least you aren’t making it easy for someone to argue that the billed charge isn’t real.

When you have a percentage discount, you may be giving insurance companies a “cheap trick” to demand lower prices. So I will close with reference to a pair of Cheap Trick songs. I hate it when I have to say to my clients, “didn’t I, didn’t I, didn’t I see you crying?”

And I hate when they “surrender, surrender.” So don’t give yourself away! Stomp out those percentage discounts. 

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn

David M. Glaser, Esq.

David M. Glaser is a shareholder in Fredrikson & Byron's Health Law Group. David assists clinics, hospitals, and other health care entities negotiate the maze of healthcare regulations, providing advice about risk management, reimbursement, and business planning issues. He has considerable experience in healthcare regulation and litigation, including compliance, criminal and civil fraud investigations, and reimbursement disputes. David's goal is to explain the government's enforcement position, and to analyze whether this position is supported by the law or represents government overreaching. David is a member of the RACmonitor editorial board and is a popular guest on Monitor Mondays.

Related Stories

Leave a Reply

Please log in to your account to comment on this article.

Featured Webcasts

Inpatient Ulcers and Gangrene: Avoid FY 2027 ICD-10-CM Coding, Sequencing, and Documentation Errors

Avoid costly inpatient coding errors involving ulcers and gangrene. This practical FY 2027 ICD-10-CM webcast clarifies pressure injury staging, non-pressure ulcer severity, diagnosis sequencing, documentation requirements, and POA reporting. Through real-world cases, gain the confidence to make defensible coding decisions, reduce denials, strengthen compliance, and support accurate reimbursement.

November 4, 2026

One Chart, Five Truths: How CDI Prevents the Same Diagnosis from Becoming Five Different Outcomes

What happens when everyone reviews the same chart, but reaches a different conclusion? In this case-based clinical documentation integrity (CDI) webcast, Penny Jefferson examines how documentation involving clinical support, timing, causation, linkage, and terminology can produce very different outcomes for ICD-10 coding, reimbursement, quality, risk adjustment, medical necessity, denials, and compliance. Using cases involving postoperative respiratory failure, severe malnutrition, and encephalopathy, you’ll learn the practical CLEAR framework to help attendees learn to evaluate whether a diagnosis is codeable, consistent, specific, reportable, and ultimately defensible across the different teams and systems that rely on the medical record.

September 30, 2026

Mastering Spinal Fusion Coding for Inpatient Facilities: ICD-10-PCS Precision, Documentation, and MS-DRG Impact

Spinal fusion cases are among the most complex inpatient procedures to code, where even minor ICD-10-PCS errors can affect MS-DRG assignment, reimbursement, compliance, and audit outcomes. This practical webcast provides a step-by-step framework for interpreting operative reports, assigning accurate ICD-10-PCS codes, recognizing documentation gaps, and confidently coding complex fusion procedures. You’ll leave with practical tools that improve coding accuracy, reduce denials and audit risk, and strengthen documentation-driven reimbursement decisions.

July 29, 2026

Trending News

Featured Webcasts

Radiation Oncology Fundamentals: Coding, Billing & Compliance for Hospital Outpatient & Professional Services

Now Available On Demand

Join Michael Calahan, PA, MBA for this radiation oncology coding and compliance webcast as he explains the fundamentals of coding, billing, reporting, and documentation for hospital outpatient and professional services. Learn how the 2026 radiation therapy coding changes affect current practices, how to distinguish technical and professional services, and how to address bundling, units, frequency, modifiers, and documentation requirements. Michael will also help you identify radiation oncology coding and billing vulnerabilities that could lead to denials, overpayments, repayment demands, or federal audit exposure.

October 20, 2026

Trending News

Celebrate Lab Week with MedLearn! Sign up to win one year of our Laboratory All Access Pass! Click here to learn more →

Have a Medicare regulation question you’d love Dr. Hirsch to answer? Now is your chance! CLICK HERE to learn more→

Happy National Doctor’s Day! Learn how to get a complimentary webcast on ‘Decoding Social Admissions’ as a token of our heartfelt appreciation! Click here to learn more →

This Memorial Day, we honor those who gave all for our freedom. Take 20% off sitewide through May 29 with code MEMORIAL26 at checkout

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 1 with code CYBER25

CYBER WEEK IS HERE! Don’t miss your chance to get 20% off now until Dec. 2 with code CYBER24